Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus

Real videos of Italian Restaurants in Columbus — 11 places, filmed by creators on the ground.

Ranked venues

Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant
View Venue
$$$RefinedElegantInvitingOn-site wineryWine pairingsSeasonal dishes
About the venue
Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant, located at 4230 the Strand in Columbus, specializes in wine country cuisine and has been in operation since 2011. Guests can enjoy a diverse menu including fresh seafood, steaks, and seasonal dishes paired with wines made on-site. The modern yet warm decor creates a refined atmosphere suitable for both casual dining and special events. Regulars appreciate the wine tasting experiences and pairing suggestions, making it a unique dining destination.
What the videos show
The video showcases a plate of spaghetti with meatballs, topped with white sauce and basil leaves. The camera pans up to reveal another plate with a burger, fries, and a small bowl of sauce.
4230 The Strand
@ohio_munchies
@ohio_munchies
The Crest Gastropub
View Venue
$$CasualInvitingCommunityCraft beersGourmet burgersSeasonal dishes
About the venue
The Crest Gastropub, located at 2855 Indianola Ave in Columbus, OH, offers a blend of traditional pub fare with modern culinary techniques. The gastropub features craft beers and an extensive wine list, providing a relaxed atmosphere suitable for casual dining. Menu highlights include gourmet burgers, elevated pub snacks, and seasonal dishes made from local ingredients. The inviting decor and community-oriented vibe make it a popular spot for friends and families looking to unwind.
What the videos show
The video showcases two plates of food, one featuring green ravioli with herbs and seeds on an orange sauce, and the other with dark-colored pasta garnished with purple sprouts, sage leaves, corn kernels, and breadcrumbs. The camera pans between the plates, highlighting their presentation.
2855 Indianola Ave
@biteswithbee
Forno Kitchen & Bar
View Venue
LivelyRusticWarmWood-fired pizzaHouse-made pastaLocal beers
About the venue
Forno Kitchen + Bar is situated on High Street in Columbus and combines American cuisine with Italian wood-fired techniques. The restaurant is known for its fresh house-made pasta and grilled pizzas, offering both during lunch and dinner hours. A highlight of the menu includes their signature wood-fired meatballs, which draw in a diverse crowd. The relaxed yet vibrant environment features a full bar with local beers and an extensive wine list, making it ideal for casual dining.
What the videos show
The video showcases a close-up of a plate of pasta with an orange sauce, featuring a dollop of white cream and herbs as garnish. The camera gradually zooms in, emphasizing the dish's presentation.
721 N High St
@mybesteats
@thisgirl_can_eat
D.P. Dough
View Venue
$CasualFast-pacedStudent-friendlyBaked calzonesLate-night hoursFast service
About the venue
D.P. Dough, located on N High St in Columbus, specializes in baked-to-order calzones since 2005. This casual eatery features a vibrant interior aimed at college students and locals. Signature menu items include the 'Buffalo Chicken Calzone' and a variety of vegetarian options. Known for its fast service and late-night hours, it’s a popular choice for students craving a quick meal after classes or partying.
What the videos show
The video shows a close-up of a D.P. Dough calzone box being opened to reveal a calzone and a small container of marinara sauce.
1259 N High St
@MealSeeker
Flatiron Tavern
View Venue
$$LivelyCasualSocialCraft beerOutdoor patioTrivia nights
About the venue
Flatiron Tavern, located at Nationwide Blvd in Columbus, features an inviting atmosphere and a diverse menu since its opening in 2018. The tavern boasts a wide selection of craft beers on tap and a menu with items ranging from burgers to vegetarian options. With both indoor seating and a spacious outdoor patio, it attracts a mix of locals and visitors looking for a relaxed dining experience. Special events like trivia nights are popular among the regular crowd.
What the videos show
The video starts with a close-up of a plate of pasta with cheese, then pans to show a man eating a sandwich and other diners enjoying their meals. A woman squeezes ketchup onto her fries while holding a carrot stick, smiling towards someone off-camera.
129 E Nationwide Blvd
@ashleybowler3
Pelino’s Pasta
View Venue
$$AuthenticCozyCasualHomemade pastaTraditional recipesFamily-run
About the venue
Pelino’s Pasta in Columbus, Ohio, has been a staple eatery since 2005, known for its authentic Italian pasta dishes made fresh in-house. The menu features a variety of pasta options including ravioli, fettuccine, and gnocchi, all paired with house-made sauces that reflect traditional Italian recipes. The warm, welcoming décor includes family photos and rustic accents, inviting a cozy dining experience. The restaurant attracts both local families and those seeking a taste of Italy.
What the videos show
The video showcases two different pasta dishes served on white plates. The first dish features wide, flat noodles with a creamy sauce and garnished with herbs. The second dish consists of spiral-shaped pasta with a green sauce and chopped nuts.
245 King Ave
@theluxehack
Trattoria Roma
View Venue
CozyFamily-orientedInvitingHomemade pastaClassic saucesOutdoor seating
About the venue
Trattoria Roma, located on Morse Rd in Columbus, Ohio, is a family-owned Italian restaurant that has been serving traditional dishes since 1999. Known for its homemade pasta and classic sauces, the eatery offers dishes like Chicken Parmesan and Margherita Pizza in a cozy, welcoming setting. Regulars appreciate the attentive service and the warm atmosphere, making it a great spot for family dinners or casual gatherings. The restaurant also features outdoor seating in the warmer months.
What the videos show
The video showcases a dining experience at Trattoria Roma, featuring various dishes such as bruschetta, chicken parmesan, and pasta with mushrooms. The camera focuses on the food and the restaurant's ambiance.
1270 Morse Rd
@_triciasanders_
Speck Italian Eatery
View Venue
RusticAuthenticInvitingHouse-made pastaCharcuterie boardsWine tastings
About the venue
Speck Italian Eatery in Columbus, Ohio, focuses on authentic Italian flavors, featuring a menu with house-made pastas and artisanal pizzas since its opening in 2021. Patrons rave about the extensive selection of cured meats and cheeses, which can be enjoyed on charcuterie boards. The venue’s rustic decor harmonizes with its culinary offering, creating a welcoming atmosphere for both locals and visitors. The eatery often holds special events such as wine tastings, making it popular among foodies in the area. A small selection of Italian wines complements the meal options well.
What the videos show
The video showcases a variety of Italian dishes and beverages at a restaurant, ending with a transition to a TikTok search bar featuring a username.
@theluxehack
Osteria pizzeria
View Venue
What the videos show
The video features a montage of three pizza restaurants in Columbus. It shows close-up shots of a skillet lasagna, a whole pizza on a wooden board, and a slice of pizza with toppings. Text overlays identify the venues as Osteria Pizzeria, Beer Barrel Pizza and Grill, and Pi of the Tiger, along with specific dish names like 'Tiger Style'.
892 Oak St
@Atmosfy
Noodles & Company
View Venue
$
What the videos show
The video presents a static, close-up shot of six meticulously arranged dishes on a wooden table, including pasta, lasagna, and other Italian-inspired meals. The table is set with utensils and napkins, suggesting a formal or home dining experience. The camera remains fixed throughout the 12-second duration, offering a consistent, unedited view of the food. There is no audio, no movement, and no human presence, emphasizing the visual appeal of the meal display. The setting appears to be a dining table in a residential or restaurant environment, with warm lighting enhancing the food's textures and colors. The composition is clean and intentional, focusing on the variety and presentation of the dishes.
2124 N High St
@alexiaajadee
Speck
View Venue
SleekItalianCozyHouse-made pastaTruffle risottoWine tastings
About the venue
Speck on N High St in Columbus is celebrated for its blend of traditional and contemporary Italian fare, established in 2015. The restaurant features distinct decor with an open kitchen, inviting diners to watch the chefs as they prepare signature dishes like truffle risotto and house-made pasta. An extensive wine list complements the menu, making it a popular dining destination for couples and groups alike. Regular events such as wine tastings enhance the experience.
What the videos show
The video showcases two plates of pasta. The first plate features pasta with sliced meat, caramelized onions, sage leaves, and a drizzled sauce. The second plate, revealed shortly after, has spaghetti with tomato sauce, white cheese, and green herbs. The background is blurred, and the focus is on the food.
67–91 N High St
@theluxehack